Is Counter Offering Worth It?

In real estate, the counter offer is used to accept some – or most – of the other party’s terms, while modifying others. It’s a common practice, but is it risky? We asked our network of over 26,000 real estate professionals if they advise their clients to counter offer. And, If so, under what conditions? Here’s what they said.

The “Perfect” Offer

When representing sellers, I always sit down and go over what components would make up their “perfect” offer. These components could range from price to closing date to having a rent-back. We also discuss what would be an “acceptable” offer. When we receive an offer that doesn’t align with the perfect offer components, we present a counter offer to try to get as close to their perfect contract as possible. If the buyers decline, we evaluate how close the offer is to their acceptable offer requirements and take it from there. Real estate is all about negotiation!

Andrea Price-Valenzuela

Price & Co.

View Andrea Valenzuela’s Real Estate Agent Profile

Always Negotiate

Negotiation is a BIG part of what I bring to the table. I’ll counter any offer, any time, if my client or I feel it is in their best interests.

Bob Gordon

Berkshire Hathaway HomeService

View Bob Gordon’s Real Estate Agent Profile

An Amiable Solution

Yes. I believe two reasonable parties can come to an agreement if good faith is shown in moving toward an amiable solution. Also, responding in a timely fashion shows respect and gratitude.

Tasya Williamson

HomeSmart Realty

View Tasya Williamson’s Real Estate Agent Profile

Common Practice

Typically, unless we get a full price offer, then yes.

Steve Thayer

Keller Williams Action Realty, LLC

View Steve Thayer’s Real Estate Agent Profile

Less than Asking Price

If the offer is anything less than the asking price.

Marilyn Johnson

Great Way RE Exclusive Properties

View Marilyn Johnson’s Real Estate Agent Profile

Your REALTOR is the best source for advice about selling your home. As an experienced real estate expert, they can help you weigh the pros and cons of individual offers, write a counteroffer, and select the best offer for your home. They can even help you navigate selling your home in Colorado’s fast-paced housing market.

Knowing when and how to counter offer is a challenge if you’re selling your home on your own. If you aren’t already working with a REALTOR, connect with a real estate professional on

Originally published January 11, 2017 — Updated May 2021.